California Propositions: Prop. 31

KCRW is taking a up-close look at one of the statewide initiatives on the November ballot.  Today, we tackle Prop 31, which deals with how that budget is drawn up—and more.

Proposition 31 is not one of those ballot measures that lends itself to short, catchy phrases.  But if you had to boil it down to fit inside a fortune cookie—or perhaps on a billboard–one possible description might be: making state government work better. But what does that mean?  KCRW’s reports:

Making government work better means  including the creation of a two-year state budget cycle; setting up benchmarks and goals for new state programs so that it’s easier to tell if they’re effective or not; requiring state lawmakers to explain how they’ll pay for new programs or tax cuts that cost $25 million or more; and giving the Governor the authority to cut the budget in financial emergencies if the legislature fails to act. “These are things that work in other states. They just seem like a big leap in California because we’ve gone so far the other way, ” said Tom McKernan, co-chair of a bipartisan group called California Forward that put Prop 31 on the ballot. He says their primary goal has been to figure out how to improve state governance.

Over the past few years, they’ve held dozens of public meetings and focus groups to get input—both from experts and from the public. And McKernan says the more they heard, the bigger an issue the state budget seemed to be. Take Prop 31’s proposal of setting up benchmarks and goals for new state programs—something the pros call performance-based budgeting. McKernan says it’s an approach that’s already used by many businesses and non-profits, and he says the state could learn a lot from it. “When we have very tight budgets, spending decisions should be focused on setting priorities and also making changes to improve performance, McKernan said.”

By glenngould via Flickr

And then there’s the part of Prop 31 that would require state lawmakers to budget out two years, instead of one. McKernan said the budget would probably have to be revised over that two year period, in situations when revenues drop sharply or costs go up unexpectedly for things like firefighting.  But he says that still wouldn’t take as long as drawing up a brand new budget every year. McKernan says ultimately the goal is that “the legislature can spend a lot more of their time on their missions, which is the quality of life for Californians in California, instead of every day it’s 24-7 budget and how do we pay for this.”

But not everyone is buying in.

“I am much more convinced that the Big Bank is needed–that incremental reform doesn’t really get to the heart of why California’s government doesn’t work very well,” said Sacramento Bee political columnist Dan Walters.  For starters, he said requiring lawmakers to draw up a two year budget isn’t practical. “They can’t even do a one year budget, much less a two year budget,” Walters said. “You cannot predict California’s revenues with any degree of certainty because the revenue structure we have is so bass ackwards, it produces these huge spikes one year and huge drops the next year, which is why they’re in budget trouble in the first place.”

And Walters said even if Prop 31 passes, lawmakers would find ways to work around it and adopt a two year budget that would fall apart a few months later. He said the bigger issue is that Prop 31 doesn’t go far enough in dealing with the dysfunction in state government in Sacramento. “What we really need is kind of a clean sheet of paper to start designing a structure of government that makes sense for what California is in the 21st century—this very large, very complex, very diverse state–rather than keep trying to put patches on the inner tube that’s springing leaks everywhere.  We need to go back and get a new inner tube.”

Walters said we need to look at the relationship between cities, counties, and the state– and who’s responsible for what.  He said we need to change the way taxes are levied and budgets produced.  And he says we need to hold a state constitutional convention to perhaps change the very structure of the legislature and how voters are represented.

Prop 31 supporters for their part say they realize the changes they’re proposing won’t fix every problem in Sacramento.  But they say if Californians can’t agree on these kinds of incremental changes, what hope is there of doing something big—like holding a state constitutional convention and changing the fundamental structure of state government?



  1. jack paker
    Apr 29, 2015, 3:49 am

    Thank you for sharing. I also share some of my story. If you are interested you can visit. vielsesringe

  2. jack paker
    Apr 15, 2015, 5:08 am

    Experience with it by their facilities and high tech advance technology use. betting tips

  • Pingback: California Elections: Voter Guide | Which Way L.A.?()


    i’d be busy once more carrying out some home decors this coming christmas, i’d be shopping for some new decors for the season”

  • Kim Kardashian Superstar

    I just couldn’t depart your web site ahead of suggesting that I definitely enjoyed the common information someone give for the guests? Is gonna be back typically to examine up on new posts

  • Connie

    I agree with "setting up benchmarks and goals" in anything we do in life, not just in government but your lifestyle, financial, and health. Keeping to these benchmarks and goals is a way to see how far you have gone, where you need to improve and make the necessary changes. Great article and thanks for giving me the opportunity to make a comment. Keep up with the good articles.

    Lose Weight Fast Now!

  • colonie de vacances

    The the following time I read a blog, Hopefully that it doesnt disappoint me up to this website. What i’m saying is, I know it was my system to read, but I personally believed youd have some issue intriguing to say. All I hear is generally a great deal of whining about something that you could fix when you werent as well busy in search of attention.

  • AlexDCN

    California is in a LOT of trouble right now, and Americans, as a whole, are way overweight. Has anyone heard of, or tried garcinia cambogia extract? Ive heard some really good things, but just waiting for more information before I plunge forward.

  • cristal

    There are actually undoubtedly a number of particulars like that to take into consideration. Which is an awesome point to carry up. I present the ideas above as regular inspiration however clearly you’ll find questions similar to the 1 you convey up where crucial factor might be working in sincere good faith. I don?t know if most effective practices have emerged around points like that, even so I’m certain that your job is clearly recognized as a fair game. Both boys and girls really feel the effect of just a second’s pleasure, for the rest of their lives.

  • faith quotes

    Of course, this does not mean to say that you can just slack off because you can always start over the next day;

  • CysticAcne Treatment

    Living in California myself, this hits home. Haven't been to this site before, but will definitely be back. Thanks for the great content.

  • leeds acupuncture

    I completely agree that keeping to these benchmarks and goals is a way to see how far we have gone, where we need to improve and make the necessary changes. Great post!

  • website

    Great content. Bookmarked the site. Thanks.

  • max my weight loss

    Prop 31 sounds like a very interesting discussion. I hope the law-makers in California make the right decision and consider the budget carefully.


  • tõhus dieet

    Yeah, they earn their sits by popping up problematic discussions

  • Go Here

    I truly enjoy looking through on this internet site , it has superb articles . “When a man’s willing and eager, the gods join in.” by Aeschylus.

  • stop smoking

    Great website with some cool post.i really love to see California.i have heard some great things about this city

  • inga

    Great Article, laser targeted planning and follow through is always the key.

  • Dr. Robert Thompson

    Hopefully the government is working on this one and will get a solution to it ASAP. Thanks for your wonderful insight regarding the subject matter.

  • @HotProbateLeads

    Even a 2 year budget that gets revised? What good would that do? If they are unwilling to reduce expenses, just agree to this years budget, then adjust up as needed… similar to the US budget

    Cut the budget

  • Terry

    Prop 31 will never work as planned. Not when they can adjust as needed.
    Mentor for Real Estate

  • Hwan

    What was the outcome of Prop 31? Improving state governance in California sounds like a good idea. I have been a licensed contractor in California and have a close and personal acquaintance with red tape!

  • Gene

    African Mango Plus: Don't Buy African Mango Diet pills Until You Check The Shocking Reviews.

  • Lissa


  • fooxjxfhndor


  • typvxbokgrrw


  • wbbffhhwfjfb


  • did you purchase this theme? mwdwnjqvti click here O:) phystdhhpifemxs, 8-| fzsaodjtfn [url=”http:/


  • ipsoxdywkcvz


  • astonishing post hfbojxvnvd click here :/ qummpgkr, :-/ majobpdkxf [url=”


  • how much money was this applications? apwtiocopy click here 8| ztbtd, :D dcnzuxtlba [url=”http://ww


  • wyzjtwkxuecl


  • loving the website ewxwzrluka click here =( buhxuvsp, :-0 zlkcecmhcg [url=”http://www.dsolkenyjdmj.


  • how much was this cms? hwpztwqqqh click here ;) nvqiubkq, B| wybvjwfrys [url=”http://www.ckeolsixkd


  • many thanks for this xiwtvzsfgp click here >:-O nkknsbgavnlv, >:o ipaznjyiai [url=”http://www


  • astonishing post zfyojxhmam click here :( ntgojsdldvobkck, :D whzzknmgub [url=”http://www.uvccoohsk


  • where did you obtain this theme? tbozaxdwrv click here O:-) kzzcspwnouowihq, :/ hlvzaalomz [url=”ht


  • awe-inspiring post opywysxase click here :[ mlbzsfahqsuz, B-| dodkepcgby [url=”http://www.yliarxoor


  • nvqhnjphoyeh


  • zzmnqsefhlyy


  • Martin Pickel

    Bla bla

  • Kim Kardashian

    I think we need a new political system where politicians actually work to improve our country instead of catering to special interests.

  • lxzejkeykeem


  • Casino en ligne

    Outstanding post! The information you have provided is outstanding. I was searching such type of content since long but finally today my search is over and all thanks to you. Your blog is not only new but constructive too. Once again appreciation.

  • click here
  • Health IT Careers

    Thanks for posting this! I will share this

  • Tina Tughnel

    The budget must not only get to span of one year but it should be for to long years. It is necessary in order to get into the tune of really progressing with the proposition.

  • Jose

    Lawmakers always seem to have a hard time getting things right. So I just sit back and work at Lafayette seo on the sidelines to see how things unfold.

  • SFranklin5

    "And he says we need to hold a state constitutional convention to perhaps change the very structure of the legislature and how voters are represented." I'd love to see this happen but I really doubt it ever will until something happens that leaves them no choice but to make the change.

  • SFranklin5

    "making state government work better. But what does that mean? " lol what does that mean…more government bolony for us tax payers to foot the bill.

  • titanium anodizing

    Thanks for the Prop 31 information. Great article.

  • Roderick Paul

    Making patches is not enough. Maybe it is but time to buy an idea that is worth believing upon.

  • ultra slim

    great post; awesome blog; subscribed!

  • oferty nieruchomościi

    s year, howe

  • darmowy katalog

    um and payment o

  • webmini www

    ss and is be

  • redagowanie pracy

    ете имати ком

  • internet marketing company sacramento

    Everything is very open with a clear description of the issues.

    It was definitely informative. Your website is very helpful.

    Thanks for sharing!

  • UGGS On Sale

    I’m extremely impressed with your writing skills as well as with the layout on your weblog. Is this a paid theme or did you customize it yourself? Either way keep up the excellent quality writing, it is rare to see a great blog like this one nowadays.

  • Tamanu Oil

    Sacramento definitely needs a lot of help.

  • sky number

    Appreciate this one, you are a great author. It's really written in depth analysis and have urged visitors to look forward more on your writing

  • {lose weight|reduce weight|slim down|drop weight|burn fat} without {a diet|a diet plan|a diet regime Lose Weight without a diet plan! Lose weight naturally. No tablets or weight loss at all. Losing weight without exercise. Shed 3 dress dimensions in less compared to a week.

  • Anita Reney

    Good point!

  • Frederik

    EH california is always in trouble lol!

    <a href"">California

  • Frederik
  • Jack
  • wózki

    Istniejeróżnica między nierdzewnymoto tudzież naprostowany .

  • inwalidzkie

    Życie istnieje akuratne , ale niektóre materyj nie wcześniejszy po prostu zbytnio zagadnienie Bea € | , względnie są po prostu sporzej ambarasów , aniżeli są warte .

  • P1 Traffic Machine

    Interesting thx

  • JoshHue

    Very interesting I will definitely try that Prolexin

  • usaha rumahan

    its to much

  • swa

    Very nice share man, I really like it.

    Thanks again!

  • To Tor

    Nice post thank’s was shared this post………….

  • jack paker

    Experience with it by their facilities and high tech advance technology use. betting tips

  • jack paker

    Thank you for sharing. I also share some of my story. If you are interested you can visit. vielsesringe