Why the NSA is bad for California business

By Lord Jim/ Flickr/ Creative Commons

California and its businesses have a problem. It’s called the National Security Agency.

That may sound provincial. The debate over the massive NSA surveillance programs disclosed by Edward Snowden is a national and global matter, not just a California concern.

But the disclosures – and the U.S. government’s reaction to them – hit at the heart of California’s economic life. The problem for California is not that the feds are collecting all of our communications. It is that the feds are (totally unapologetically) doing the same to foreigners, especially in their communications with Americans.

California’s leading industries—shipping, tourism, technology, and entertainment—could not survive, much less prosper, without the trust and goodwill of foreigners. We are home to two of the world’s busiest container ports, and all of our signature companies—Apple, Google, Facebook, Oracle, Intel, Hewlett-Packard, Chevron, Disney—rely on sales and growth overseas. Our families and workplaces are full of foreigners; more than one in four of us were born abroad.

The response from America’s leaders?  “With respect to the Internet and emails, this does not apply to U.S. citizens and it does not apply to people living in the United States,” said President Obama, as if the privacy and trust of foreigners were of no consequence. Similarly, James Clapper, the director of national intelligence, said that the Prism program, which taps into online communications, “could not be used to intentionally target any U.S. citizen.”

Such statements should be chilling to Californians.

Will tourists balk at visiting us because they fear U.S. monitoring? Will overseas business owners think twice about trading with us because they fear that their communications might be intercepted and used for commercial gain by American competitors? Most chilling of all: Will foreigners stop using the products and services of California technology and media companies—Facebook, Google, Skype, and Apple among them—that have been accomplices (they say unwillingly) to the federal surveillance?

The answer to that last question: Yes. It’s already happening. Asian governments and businesses are now moving their employees and systems off of Google’s Gmail and other U.S.-based systems, according to news reports. The issue is becoming a stumbling block in negotiations with the European Union over a new trade agreement. Technology experts are warning of a big loss of foreign business.

Unfortunately, California is in a poor position to do anything about all of this, since we are part of the United States. As USC’s Abraham F. Lowenthal observed in his indispensable book Global California, “California has the power as well as the global links and interests of a nation” but “it lacks the legal attributes and policy instruments of a sovereign country.”

Being an American state is an enormous headache at times like these. It doesn’t help when our own U.S. Sen. Dianne Feinstein is backing the surveillance without acknowledgment of the huge potential costs to her state.

It’s time for her and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, who has been nearly as tone-deaf on this issue, to be forcefully reminded that protecting California is at least as important as protecting massive government data-mining.

Californiahas a robust history of going its own way—on vehicle standards, energy efficiency, immigration, marijuana. Now is the time for another departure—this one on the privacy of communications.

I’m not a big fan of ballot measures, but on this issue we may need a state constitutional amendment,to make plain that California considers the personal data and communications of all people, be they American or foreign, to be private and worthy of protection.

Such a measure wouldn’t stop NSA surveillance, nor should it. But it would give California-based companies some leverage to resist the most invasive surveillance demands of federal agencies. And it would send an unmistakable message to California’s friends that we care about protecting their privacy—and keeping their business.

Joe Mathews wrote this Connecting California column for Zócalo Public Square.






  1. ケイトスペード
    Apr 22, 2014, 11:26 pm

    Plus who can resist all the shiny purse frames! For church groups, seniors citizens or even youth groups, it may be the form of project a
    person been seeking. Abandon them pretty unique looking and many families love to
    use them commercially a associated with purposes.
    I am associated with being the hidden wife, separated from her husband by a
    church that values religion over friends and family.

  2. Present Viewer
    Mar 29, 2014, 7:21 pm

    really enjoyed your writing style! just couldnt stop reading! Thanks :D

  • Admiring the hard work you put into your website and in depth information you offer.

    It’s good to come across a blog every once in a while that isn’t the same unwanted rehashed material.

    Excellent read! I’ve bookmarked your site and I’m adding your RSS feeds to my Google


  • very nice post, i certainly really like this website, keep on it
    how to get off dialysis http://journals.fotki.com/quit96faucet/ways-kidney-disease-c-832/entry/dkfbbkbrqfww/

  • But what about chapter 11

  • Jmanza18

    Communication systems will always be in the "limelight" due to governments, conspiricies and the stigma that comes along with anything digital. It is an issue that will always be here and with technology improving so much we need to learn to deal with and live with it as it is here to stay unfortunately…
    Go have a look at <a href="http://www.pandp.co.za” target=”_blank”>www.pandp.co.za for more info!

  • Made A person Seen Of which Samsung Unveils Corby HandsetsSamsung provides intrdouced a couple unique mobile phones to make sure you a to line of home equipment Coby, any younger people inside Eu to become adedd. The ultra-modern versions incllude any Coprby Corby (TXT) not to mention Coprby (PRO), which might be available in addition to any originaal Corby S3650-Mobile, presently availlable. A Cotrby (TXT) is in addition knnown for the B3210 and possesses a new 2. 2-inch LCD, 2MP dslr camera through online video media assist, included FM tuner, adjustable goes over, not to mention 40 MB about on the machine storage expandable by having a microSD cartomancy slot machine. His phone blends with BORDER GPRS structures Quad-band. A mobilephone could be availabe inside Eu till the conclude about Sept. A Crby (PRO) handet features a QWERTY kyboard not to mention works out within the 900 2100MHz HSDPA 7. 2Mbps mobile phone network. A phpone carries a 2. 8-inch touchscreen technology LCD assist and will be offering a new 3MP dslr camera. A dslr camera can track record a new online video media. Otehr includes comprise a Radio through RDS, easily removed insure, Wi-Fi, Bluuetooth, Mirco UNIVERSAL SERIES BUS, 100 MB storage accompanied by a microSD cartomancy slot machine plus more. A mobilephone will certainly send inside Nov. Doing this Reasons for having A LG KP500 Phone PhoneMobile phonees will be just around basically connecting units. At this time, some of us try to be contemporary thewse units, gammes games consoles not to mention service about World wide web expert services. Good to find out which will thhese microscopic systems are already with success discover a lot of these fundamental featurers. A LG KC910 is normally a clever mobile phones that can be avaoilable within the mobile phone emails economy. It pohne posseses an phrase which will simply leaves a new full imprint within the heads about clients. Should you be fervent abotu any dslr camera, which will touch a new couplpe about images about superior then simply this specific LG phne is normally obligatory for you personally. There is 8-megapixel dslr camera could be the imzage solution about 3264 times 2448 pixels. Morover, this specific machine has also includes for example automotive target, online video media recordinng, not to mention vidoe dslr camera phone. Gamerts will probably often be happpy with this particular machine, when they comes with sophisticated efatures superb match. They have various matches that you could participate in aytime not to mention any where. In the toher hands, this specific machine will come in black colored coloor, that is certainly the most accepted color choice all over the world. By way of acquiring this specific machine implies that you could post not to mention be given e-maipls through attachemnts in a very a lot more rapiid manner. It phoone could be great for individuals so, who quite often want to investigate his or her email address whle they are simply not really facing his or her Computer systems. LG KP500 Cereal bar an additional unit out of LG is really a qualified supplier. It kind Cereal bar cellular phone provides countless includes which will without a doubt come up with any mpobile consumers will be dependnet in it. It wonderful system will come in a few colorations, for example black colored, Vandyke red, anodized silcver not to mention jewelry sophisticated. You should purchase this specific cellular phone inside all of these colorations. There’s a lot of folks who adore to get mobile phones as per thheir favoruite colorations not to mention horoscope. It communicationms machine features a dslr camera 3. 2 brilliant pixels whicch any impression reslution about 2048 times 1536 pxels. It dslr camera might take premium imaegs, sign in forums obtain tese images over the internet, help save on your laptop and also remove them about prrint not to mention, hence, available these folks. Through standby way, a battery pack is normally 350 hrs not to mention discussion this specific machine.

  • I'm not a big fan of election measures, but on this affair we may charge a accompaniment built-in amendment,to accomplish apparent that California considers the claimed abstracts and communications of all people, be they American or foreign, to be clandestine and aces of protection.

  • opaler

    What I have against the NSA, besides what everybody else has – which is the fact that they're listening to every conversation you'll ever make, thus turning privacy in this country a thing of the past- is that there is no real authority on who they can spy on, thus breaking one of the fundamental rights. I was hoping to find a solution on http://www.globalcheckrecovery.com/ but there was nothing about the NSA there.

  • And, by the way the NSA stinks to high heaven!

  • really enjoyed your writing style! just couldnt stop reading! Thanks :D

  • Plus who can resist all the shiny purse frames! For church groups, seniors citizens or even youth groups, it may be the form of project a
    person been seeking. Abandon them pretty unique looking and many families love to
    use them commercially a associated with purposes.
    I am associated with being the hidden wife, separated from her husband by a
    church that values religion over friends and family.